NME Video Blog - The best music clips -  The best music clips

By Luke Lewis

Posted on 08/04/09 at 04:32:58 pm

 

Time was when a new Eminem single would generate a global media scrum, with every mag/website/TV station falling over each other to bag the exclusive. 'We Made You', however, seems to have been greeted with a collective shrug.

Perhaps that's because the song, and the video, generate such a powerful feeling of déjà-vu. All the targets feel out-of-date – Britney Spears, Amy Winehouse. It's as if the lyrics were written with search engines in mind. A passing reference to Sarah Palin is the only evidence that Marshall Mathers has switched on a TV since 2006.

continued...

Plus, post Nickelback, using the term "rock star" to skewer celebrity pomposity/self-delusion feels horribly stale. Elsewhere, Eminem clichés abound. There's the reference to prescription pills (Zantac, in this case); the jabbering, Eric Cartman-esque vocals, with Shady spewing grossout double entendres straight out of 'American Pie' ("I'm beginning to sprout an alfalfa").

Then there's the video, which borrows visual themes from 'Star Trek' and 'Jailhouse Rock'. Whoa, cutting-edge.

Eminem's popularity arose from his unerring ability to catch the zeitgeist (in 'My Name Is' he namechecked The Spice Girls, in 'The Real Slim Shady' it was Fred Durst and Viagra). But 'We Made You' suggests he's not only stopped finding absurdity in the world around him, he's actually bored of being himself.

NME.COM blogs contain the opinions of the individual writer and not necessarily those of NME magazine or NME.COM.

22 comments

Add comment

 
 
Alex [Visitor] //April 8 2009 at 19:03
So he disses Amy, Brit and more of the easiest targets in show business - not exactly ground breaking is it? He should have done something a bit more cutting edge for his big comeback.
shady [Visitor] //April 8 2009 at 20:42
The song is great as is the video, NME spend too much time bumming celebritys like Winehouse, mocking her is not out of date she is in the papers and on your website constantly! Eminem is the greatest lyricist of our generation, this song is another great song SHADY IS BACK
Bill [Visitor] //April 8 2009 at 20:51
All of the first singles Eminem has released have had a similar fun sound, I don't see any difference in this. In my opinion it's a good thing. Saying he's run out of ideas before anyone has heard the album is ridiculous. This is just one track. I look forward to hearing the rest of the album.
alex [Visitor] //April 8 2009 at 22:47
nme ur so wrong about this song its quite modern u have to remember that artist evolve also
Emily [Visitor] //April 8 2009 at 23:05
Bit sad that he would rap over a song that swings...when he doesn't know how to keep time in that mode.
Hello [Visitor] //April 9 2009 at 01:46
Em should jus go back 2 cocaine and then moaning about it, but.... He was a raw talent! Just wish it was 98 again... For his sake only x
Marty J [Visitor] //April 9 2009 at 10:12
Eminem was always shit. He sounds like a hyperactive nerd. When are Jurassic-5 reforming?
Carolina [Visitor] //April 9 2009 at 13:39
I actually agree with NME's review. I also have to say that I was already expecting something like this. It's his comfort zone and he probably thought that if it worked before it is going to work again. The thing is, the market and mentalities evolve and you get to a point where you're begging for something new, different, out of the box. And it is so obvious that Eminem does not have that ability. I keep on thinking that the only rapper who has that ability is Kanye West. Also, I find it quite annoying that he makes a living out of other celebrities' misfortune.
4kingkas [Visitor] //April 9 2009 at 16:22
its not great. crack a bottle is better. the beat is awesome!
yahum [Visitor] //April 9 2009 at 20:47
Well the entire articles negative view on repetition is flawed, he has released ALL of his albums with songs like this leading the way, it's more commercially acceptable so of course this gets released, and It's not exactly to top what your name is when you're eminem and you have had the success he has had. Song is good, video is good, its same old Eminem, I don't know what the people hating it are expecting.
Andy [Visitor] //April 10 2009 at 03:01
Well I'll be listening to the new album. Love J5 but I don't see them coming back.
Mex [Visitor] //April 10 2009 at 03:30
I think eminem is a very good artist, but for he took release this type of music is a great dissappointment...nothing new, nothing original, is the old slim shady dead?
aussie_prince_ [Visitor] //April 10 2009 at 08:08
No Eminem, I didn't miss you.
musac fan [Visitor] //April 10 2009 at 17:22
i agree with shady, em is clearly by far the most talented rapper, i mean look at his platinum history, plus dont you think you should listnen to the whole album before critisizing him. SHADY IS BACK
Jason [Visitor] //April 10 2009 at 22:13
This is awful, that is all that needs to be said.
LyricalTerrorist [Visitor] //April 11 2009 at 12:14
Never really liked him anyway, this is ok thou. Just waiting for the new Dre album personally.
Karen [Visitor] //April 11 2009 at 16:05
This is just typical Eminem juvenile pop/rap. I find him very irritating and pointless, his music past and present are mind numbing. All he ever does is slate other performers while dishing out boring music time after time, i wish he would just go away or something!! It's a terrible video and song,
Dan (UK) [Visitor] //April 20 2009 at 14:50
IF ITS NOT BROKE THEN DONT FIX IT!! So why should eminem change?? he is as great as when he left and we like him for his music whether its dated or not, he's original so find something else to get a reaction from, and i thought writers were clever
theo28 [Visitor] //April 20 2009 at 22:36
doesnt seem that long ago to me when this guy was truly challenging and cutting edge now its all vaguely embaressing -i guess its hard to be pissed off when your a millionaire . some one clever should do a graph between money and talent. It seems theres a connection - maybe you need that hunger. Having said that Cash was awesome in to his late seventies. Eminem - it breaks my heart to say it but , you SUCK ! gonna lie in dark room now .....
Jane (uk) [Visitor] //April 29 2009 at 16:49
Eminem is clearly obsessed with celebrities. This makes him a loser. Pop stars are supposed to be cool & make culture interesting. He raps about people who, in five years time, no one will remember. Why should we care who Kim Kardasin is?
austin [Visitor] //May 5 2009 at 10:33
you all need to listen to the new song with him and dre bet your opinion changes drastically
Starr [Visitor] //June 14 2010 at 03:29
Don't care what all you haters say, you just wish you that you were brilliant of a lyricist as Eminem. He can publicly put down anyone with his one-line-sinkers off the top of is head, & they are usually true. Love you Eminem, keep on doing what you do

This post has 1 feedback awaiting moderation...

Leave a comment:

 
 

Note: HTML tags are not allowed
 

<< Previous post: Intense Humming Of Evil - 10 Tracks That Reference Charles Manson

Next post: 'Red Dwarf: Back To Earth' - This Weekend's Essential Viewing >>

Free weekly music news, videos and MP3s in your inbox: